If you’re seeing this, it means that our shop is currently closed for pre-orders.

All that really means is that you can be first in line when our shop re-opens for pre-orders this coming Saturday at 9 a.m. sharp!

Until then, you can still browse all of our delicious products below. Which ones will find a home in your cart when pre-orders open?

$25.99
Can’t decide? Hey, we get it. Which is why this discounted bundle exists!
Our Cookie Sampler Pack contains one (1) of each of the following:
- THE Cookie
- Dark Chocolate Toffee Cookie
- Oreo Birthday Cake Cookie
- Espresso Dark Chocolate Chunk Cookie
- Brown Sugar Chai Cookie
- Brown Butter Crunch Cookie
We’re flexible though, so if you’d like a different combination of six (6) cookies, just leave us a note at the checkout and we’ll be happy to customize your Cookie Sampler Pack!

$4.99
The cookie that started it all!
A recipe that has been obsessed over and perfected for years; we believe a good chocolate chip cookie can set any bakery apart from the rest. And ours is truly the best, making it THE Cookie for good reason. Crispy edges with a soft, chewy, centre and just the right amount of premium milk and dark Belgian chocolate. Topped with flaky salt for the perfect balance of salty and sweet.
This is the one that will keep you coming back again and again.

$4.99
Think butter can’t hold its own as a cookie flavour? Think again.
We’ve taken our signature soft and chewy dough and leveled it up with the rich, nutty magic of toasty brown butter. But it doesn’t stop there; to add even more flavour, we fold in our beloved house-made toffee bits (if you know, you know), and caramelized Corn Flakes for a satisfying crunch.
Deeply flavourful with a crave-worthy texture, Brown Butter Crunch is sweet, salty, buttery, and has a ton more personality than your average cookie.

$4.99
You’re not ready for how good these are 🤤 The fudgiest dark chocolate cookies loaded with house-made toffee and even more dark chocolate.
We make our toffee from scratch because… of course we do! That’s just how we do things at Butter Bakery. Store bought toffee bits have nothing on our rich and flavourful toffee chunks that get absolutely loaded into our dark chocolate cookie dough. You’ll taste the difference in these cookies and it may ruin all other toffee cookies for you.
We don’t like to pick favourites around here… but these may just be our favourite of the bunch (don’t tell the others 🤭)!

$4.99
A celebration in every bite!
Our signature cookie dough gets a birthday cake twist and is loaded up with white chocolate chips, Oreo pieces and sprinkles. Topped with a birthday cake drizzle and even more sprinkles. Grab one of these cookies and let the celebration begin! We won’t tell anyone if that celebration is a birthday, or just because it’s a Tuesday.
It’s the ultimate gift for someone special, even if that someone is you! 😉

$4.99
This cookie is like a delicious, warm hug.
Cozy chai spices combined with our soft and chewy brown sugar cookie dough. Finished off with a sweet chai drizzle and some toasted milk crumbs. It’s like your favourite tea latte in a delicious cookie form.
Perfectly spiced and subtly sweet, it’s the ultimate afternoon pick me up with your favourite tea or coffee.

$11.99
Imagine the best qualities of cinnamon rolls and focaccia bread… now imagine them all together in one crispy, chewy, gooey bite; that’s our Cinnamon Roll Focaccia.
Crispy focaccia edges combined with a soft and fluffy interior loaded with a gooey brown sugar and cinnamon filling. Topped off with a creamy vanilla bean glaze for that perfect sweet finish.
Trust us when we say you’re going to have a hard time putting this one down.
Serves 4-5 (depending on appetite!) This loaf can be cut into 4 very generous slices.

$4.99
Our signature soft and chewy cookie dough gets a bold, caffeinated glow-up!
We’ve infused it with rich espresso and loaded it with our very own Espresso Dark Chocolate Bark. If you love coffee and dark chocolate (who doesn’t?) you’re going to love this one.
Subtly sweet and perfectly bold. Perfect for a mid-day pick-me-up, no espresso machine required! It’s the ultimate wake up call for your taste buds.

10.99
You’ve never had a sourdough loaf like this before.
Our signature sourdough dough gets enriched with butter to give you the absolute best of qualities of a croissant and sourdough combined. It has the light and airy texture of a croissant with the signature sour tang and chew you love in sourdough. The best part is the rich buttery flavour this loaf has. So good you could eat it on its own, but it’s even better paired with one of our infused butters.
We wish we could bottle the smell that wafts throughout the kitchen while these loaves are baking.

$8.99
Our signature, house-made butter. We couldn’t call ourselves Butter Bakery without giving you the best butter you’ll ever have, right? Once we whip the butter, we fold in flaky Maldon sea salt to add the perfect clean and crunchy salt bite.

$8.99
Smoky, aromatic charred scallions are folded into our whipped salted butter. It has a rich and caramelized onion flavour that is perfect on toast with eggs or to use in your cooking. Toss it into your pasta or rice for an extra level of flavour that you won’t regret.

$8.99
Salted Maple is your new favourite flavour combination!
Real maple syrup combined to perfection with our light and fluffy whipped butter. A touch of vanilla bean and flaky salt for a decadent balance of creamy, salty and sweet. Pairs beautifully with our Honey Oat and Croissant Sourdough breads. You’ll love it on pancakes, banana bread or stirred into your morning oatmeal.